Don't Blow Up Your Nose: Is Balloon Sinuplasty a Revolutionary Treatment?
  • Blog Home
  • Sinus
  • Don't Blow Up Your Nose: Is Balloon Sinuplasty a Revolutionary Treatment?
By Mark T. Brown, MD, FACS
December 02, 2013
Category: Sinus
Tags: Sinus   Mark Brown   Balloon Sinuplasty   Surgery  

   

 

     Every now and then in medicine a new technique comes along that revolutionizes the field. Imagine a world without cardiac catheterization and repair of coronary disease. How about living in a time without penicillin? These are two of the myriad medical advances that have improved the lives of people worldwide since the 1940s. Balloon sinuplasty is NOT one of those advances despite the advertising.

    Sinus surgery has evolved over the years to the remarkably effective procedure we have today. The introduction of endoscopes brought a level of safety not seen before. Operating in the nose where the sinuses drain to improve the natural function of the nose has resulted in great success for patients. As with any operation there are risks, and some of them are pretty scary. However, in experienced hands those risks are minimized and patient outcomes are excellent.

     Enter the new technique. The balloon has evolved for use in the nose from the aforementioned cardiac catheterization. The idea is that we dilate the sinus opening (instead of physically removing tissue to enlarge it), drainage improves, and chronic infection resolves. Unfortunately, there is no data to show that this is a safer or more effective technique than standard approaches. Is it bad? Probably not. Is it safer? Probably not. Is it marketable? Very much so!

    The marketing strategy has been direct to consumers – “ask your doctor about…” – and to primary care doctors – “send your patients for balloon sinuplasty.” To me that is, at best, medically meddlesome. At worst it may be unethical.

    Balloon sinuplasty is not evil. It is a tool that, when applied correctly, has applicability to modern sinus care. It is not proven to be safer or more effective. Nor has it proven to be unsafe or less effective. It is what it is, a tool. Don’t be taken in by the advertising. Go to a doctor who focuses on patient care, not the marketing of a technique.

    Oh by the way, there is one thing balloon sinuplasty excels at - increasing the price of a procedure.                  

 

 

Mark T. Brown, MD, FACS

Dr. Mark Brown is an Otolaryngologist (Ear, Nose and Throat) specialist at Great Hills ENT in Austin, TX. Dr. Brown is Board Certified in both Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery as well as Sleep Medicine. Great Hills ENT serves the greater Austin area including Georgetown, Cedar Park, Lago Vista, Jonestown, Steiner Ranch, Lakeway, Spicewood and Point Venture. We are proud to provide excellent care to our patients for general Ear, Nose and Throat (ENT) services, hearing loss, dizziness/vertigo and sleep disorders.

Image is not a licensed Simpsons™ graphic and is not meant to be an actual representation by  Matt Groening or the Fox Broadcasting Company.

 

Comments: